Click for ILDA home page
Click for more information about Pangolin's Beyond software
 

 

 

Javascript DHTML Drop Down Menu Powered by dhtml-menu-builder.com  
 

 

Support for ILDA's research and public information activities for the Russian incident comes from the following Members who made special donations. They have our deep appreciation in supporting the lasershow industry:

William R. Benner, Jr, Pangolin Laser Systems Hugo Bunk, Laserimage b.v. Joseph Suehle, Image Engineering Alberto Kellner, Laser Entertainment s.r.l. George Dodworth, Lightwave Int'l. Alexander Timofeyev, Orion-Art Production Greg Makhov, LSDI Inc. Michael Sollinger, LaserAnimation Sollinger Paul Berthot, Clandestine Systems Edwin Dolby, Laser Productions Dave Nash, FFP Laser Systems


July 5 2008 Russian incident


Statement by ILDA's Executive Director
Mon., July 14, 2008

Last updated Wed. July 16, 2008 14:00GMT (10:00 AM U.S. EDT)
See also our press release of July 22, 2008

Click for Italian text / Fare clic sul pulsante per testo italiano Read this page in Italian / Leggere questa pagina in italiano
 

According to news reports beginning on July 14, lasers caused eye damage at the Aquamarine Open Air Festival, a rave near Moscow, Russia. At the July 5 event, "dozens of partygoers" reported eye injuries including partial vision loss. Digital camera and camcorder sensors were also damaged. The cause was reported to be due to a laser show originally intended to be pointed at the sky, which was instead aimed down into the audience due to rainy conditions.

The Aquamarine situation was an extraordinary event. Since laser shows started 40 years ago, there have been thousands of audience-scanning laser shows presented daily, with millions of enthralled viewers. In all this time, there have only been two reports of mass injuries; both were caused by misuse of a type of pulsed laser which should never be aimed at an audience.

Pulsed lasers confirmed

For this reason, ILDA initially suspected pulsed lasers were in use. Based on video of the event, this seems to be confirmed. Beam patterns on a wall show a dotted line instead of solid. This is characteristic of pulsed lasers which emit short, powerful bursts of light.

Pulsed lasers are fine for sky and overhead use, but they should NOT be used for audience scanning.1  This is because the pulses can pack 100 times the power of an equivalent continuous-wave laser which should be used instead. These emit a steady flow of light with constant power.

Injury-causing lasers far exceed safety standards

The Aquamarine lasers were being used irresponsibly and probably illegally. To cause such injuries, the audience exposure must have far exceeded agreed-upon international laser safety standards (IEC 60825-1 "Safety of Laser Products" and 60825-3 "Guidance for Laser Shows and Displays"). These standards cover aspects such as the beam intensity and scanning speed at the audience. Many countries have laws which are derived from these standards. Even in countries where there are no laser-specific laws and regulations, the IEC safety standards should be followed.

All ILDA Members are required to perform safe shows which follow the standards and their local laws. No ILDA Member was involved with the Aquamarine rave show.

ILDA's response and actions

First and foremost, our deepest thoughts and concerns go out to those who were injured.

ILDA was extremely distressed to hear about this incident. It appears that the lasers at this event were being used irresponsibly, haphazardly, not in accordance with international safety standards, and potentially illegally.

We have asked our Members for any additional information. At this time, we are only getting press reports. ILDA does not know the name of the laser company responsible for this, or any confirmed details about the laser equipment or usage.

Within a few hours of first hearing the news on July 14, ILDA's Board of Directors held a meeting via teleconference. They issued an initial statement based on the then-known facts. They also directed the ILDA Safety Committee to monitor the incident and to report on any changes in procedures or standards which may be necessary.

Laser shows are exciting for audiences. Being inside precisely-choreographed lightshapes is a wonderful experience. ILDA remains committed to safety first, and to having laser shows remain safe and pleasurable.


For additional information

Click to jump to:

 

FAQ -- July 5 Moscow incident

How could this happen?

At this time, details remain sketchy. Some reports say that the lasers were originally intended for a sky or overhead show. But due to rain, the lasers were aimed downwards, under a tent, which put them into the audience. This type of pulsed laser NEVER should have been aimed into the crowd.

A few reports said the show was aimed at the tent and light was "refracted" into the audience. This would have been much safer. Unfortunately, the video shows the beams going directly into the audience, so the refraction theory is not viable.
 

Who is responsible?

Under standard laser safety practices, the laser operator is responsible for the safe operation of the show. One or more operator is required to be onsite, monitoring the show, and turning off the laser immediately in case of any problem.

Even if promoters or audience members re-aimed the pulsed laser from the sky into the audience, a laser operator should have been aware of the hazard and should have stopped the laser immediately. 
 

I read that drugs may have caused the damage? Is this true?

A July 15 story in Kommersant, "Russia's Daily Online", says there could be other factors:

"The official reason, i.e., the improper use of laser at the discotheque, raises questions, a source with the medical community said on condition of anonymity. According to eye doctors, the real cause could be drug consumption but this lead calls for additional checking....[O]pthalmologists revealed no retina burns in the end, while the actual diagnosis was etimopathy [retinopathy] of hemorrhagic form, as all young victims had haemorrage on the eyeground [sic] and retina."

The fact that camera and camcorder sensors were damaged indicates that the lasers were far too powerful. Drugs may have made the eye damage worse, by widening the pupil (letting in more light) or by some other mechanism. But the primary cause appears from the video to be due to using the wrong type of laser for audience scanning.


How bad are the injuries?

They are not pleasant, but based on the July 15 report, they are better than intially indicated. Retinal burns are more permanent than retinal hemorrhages. One is a burn, the other is similar to a bruise. The long term effects -- whether there is permanent vision loss, whether it is in the center of vision or in peripheral vision, etc. -- remain to be seen.
 

Why did the injured people wait a day or more to seek treatment?

In a rave situation, there is so much stimulation and excitement that a person may not immediately recognize a loss of vision. Or, their vision problems may be attributed to the flashing stage lights, alcohol and/or drug usage, smoke in the air, etc. Only later, when looking at a blue sky or uniform white wall, might someone notice spots and seek treatment.
 

When I read about this online, there are a lot of different pictures of lasers, next to the stories. Are these all from the July 5 Aquamarine show?

As of July 16, almost all of these images are "stock photos" of laser shows. A few were from an earlier Aquamarine rave (in previous years). Please don't think that all these laser shows in the stock images are unsafe!

 

FAQ - Laser safety

Is laser light some special type of light or radiation?

Visible laser light, like that used in laser shows, is like ordinary, conventional light from bulbs except more concentrated (coherent). Laser safety signs may say "Caution - Laser radiation". This refers to ordinary light radiation, like that from the sun or light bulbs or the flames of a fire. It is not the same as much-higher powered ionizing or nuclear radiation.

The eye can be damaged by bright conventional light, such as staring into the sun or looking closely at flashes from arc welders. Similarly, the eye can be damaged by bright visible-wavelength laser light, if too much enters the eye and stays on the retina for too long. The retina overheats and can be permanently damaged.
 

What makes laser light hazardous?

There are three main factors of laser danger: power, divergence and exposure time:

  • Power is how much light comes out. It is like water from a hose -- you can have a pleasant stream or the blast from a fire hose.
  • Divergence is how focused the light is. Again, it is like a wide fan of water versus a narrow spray.
  • Exposure time is how long the light stays on the retina. A quick scan across the retina spreads out the power, as opposed to staring into the light which focuses it on one area.


In the Russian news video, the reporter burns a bag with a laser pointer. Doesn't that show that even small lasers are dangerous?

Laser pointers in the U.S. are supposed to be limited to 5 milliwatts in power. At this level, a person hit by the beam can blink within 1/4 second, without any effect from the beam.

The laser pointer in the Russian news video is above 5 mW. It has to be, in order to cause the burning bag. Also note that the laser pointer is close to the bag -- the beam divergence is very small at this distance. And note that the bag is black. This absorbs heat; a white bag would not burn.

You can't really compare a stationary laser close to a thin black flammable surface, with a moving laser that is much farther from the audience's eyes. A valid safety analysis of the latter is more complex.
 

How do laserists make a safe show?

Doing safe laser shows means that the operator must be aware of the power, divergence and exposure time. They must use limited power, with a beam that is slightly "fat", and the beam should be kept moving. Any higher powers or static beams should be above the audience.

(Sometimes tricks are used, such as having high powered beams above the audience which automatically dim when they go into the audience. Because the audience is looking directly at the dimmed beams, the overall brightness appears to be the same as the overhead beams.)
 

Continuous vs. pulsed lasers

Lasers used in audience scanning shows should be continuous. This means the light is continuously emitted. Pulsed lasers can be extremely dangerous because they pack their output power into short bursts.1

It is the difference between someone putting their fist on your arm and pressing continuously, and if they pull back and put the same energy into one short punch (pulse). Your arm can take the continuous energy, but not the same amount in a short burst.

If you have a 40W argon (continuous) and a 40W Nd:YAG (pulsed), they both emit the same amount of energy. However, each 600 nanosecond YAG pulse has 70 times the energy as the argon's beam, during the pulse timespan. This means it is 70 times more hazardous. Said another way, the YAG appears to the eye as if it was a 2800W laser.

1 Note: Under some special circumstances, pulsed lasers may be able to safely scan audiences. ILDA is working to clarify those factors. In the meantime, we suggest doing no audience scanning with pulsed lasers at this time.
 

Industrial laser accidents vs. audience accidents

There have been eye damage accidents in laboratory or industrial settings. Usually the injured person is close to the laser output -- within a meter or two. The beam at this distance is very small and tight, such as a few millimeters in diameter.

For audience scanning shows, the audience is usually much farther away. The beam spreads out to the size of a coin or even larger. This helps lower the chance of injury, all other factors such as beam power being equal. This is why lab/industry accident rates cannot be extrapolated to audience situations. 

 

Additional links

ILDA Safety Panel Statement on Audience Scanning
A review of international standards and guidelines for safe audience scanning. Developed by an ILDA panel of experts in 1998.

Making Shows Safe and Enjoyable
An article by William Benner Jr. of Pangolin Laser Systems, about audience scanning safety.

 


2004-2011 International Laser Display Association. All rights reserved.
No reproduction of text or images on this site is allowed without written permission of ILDA or other copyright holder(s). "ILDA" and the ILDA logo are trademarks of the International Laser Display Association.

ILDA WEBSITE AT-A-GLANCE

 
   Most-used website pages

Home page
What's new with ILDA  (latest news)
----------------------------
Become a Member  (for non-members)
Become Accredited (for laser show companies)
Renew for this year  (for Members)
Member Management website
Contact us  (address, phone, etc.)

Safety links & articles

 

    For laser show clients

Find a laser display company:
      Directory of ILDA Accredited Professionals
      ----------------------------
      Directory of ILDA Members, alphabetical
      Directory of ILDA Members, geographical

      Directory of ILDA Members, searchable database

      Members who renewed for 2011
      ----------------------------
     
Submit an inquiry about a specific project
      Contact ILDA

See our Members' work:
      Places to see laser shows
      Latest shows and projects
      New products and services
     
Press releases from our members
      ----------------------------
      Sign up for Laserist list email
      ----------------------------
      Laser art book: "World of Manick Sorcar"

     
Articles by and about ILDA

Why use lasers:
     
Complete Guide to Laser Shows
     -----------------------------
      Why lasers?
     
Atmospheric beam effects
     
Animated graphics
     
The show
      
Technology

Consumer protection:
    
 ILDA Accreditation helps ensure qualifications
      ILDA Code of Ethics protects you
      Ethics Complaint Form (file a complaint)
      Ethics Complaint List (active complaints)
      What does it mean that a company is an ILDA Member?

     -----------------------------
      Internet and eBay fraud warning
      Safety links & articles
      Laser effects on cameras and camcorders
     -----------------------------
     Are you being harassed by lasers?

     
For laser pointers:
        Safety warning: "DVD Laser Flashlight Hack"

        Laser Pointer Safety website

Inquiries and referrals (find a company, book a show, ask a question)
 

   For all laserists

Become an ILDA Member
ILDA Pro (IAPLC) accreditation

-----------------------------
Laser Safety Officer course
Online Store website
ILDA mailing lists:
      ILDA and Laserist mailing lists
      ILDA BuySell mailing list
-----------------------------
Safety links & articles
Links to related sites

 

 
   For ILDA members

Members-Only pages:
     
How to get a Members-Only password
      -----------------------------
      New Member information
      ILDA Award photos for Members
   
  ILDA logos for Member use
   
  ILDA logo policy
      -----------------------------
   
  Insurance
    
 Insurance & shipping liability
      -----------------------------
     Audience scanning: Measurements and MPE levels

     Audience scanning: Suggested practices
    
U.S. national laser laws and regulations 
     U.S. import laws:

           U.S. laser laws affecting importers
           CDRH-ILDA letters, Nov. 2007
           Discussion of U.S. import laws
      Local laser laws and regulations
      Avoiding damage to cameras and projectors
      -----------------------------
    
 Technical standards
      "Undergraduate Photons" paper
      -----------------------------
    
 ILDA Bylaws
    
 Board meeting minutes:
            2011
            2010    2009

            2008    2007 
            2006 and earlier

      -----------------------------
     ILDA tradeshow reports:
            SIB, April 2008 in Rimini
            Show-way, Feb. 2008, Bergamo
            -----------------------------
            LDI, Nov. 2007, Orlando
            PALME, May 2007, Dubai

Member Management website & Online Store
Password help

Update your listings
----------------------------
Renewals:
      Quick and easy renewal process
      Members who renewed for 2011
     -----------------------------
      Members who renewed for 2010
      Members who renewed for 2009


Membership information:
      Member Management website (renew, conference registration, etc.)
      How to check your Membership status & listings

      How to update your Membership listing
      How to renew your Membership

      How to make payments via PayPal or credit card
      -----------------------------
      Membership FAQ
      Branch office policy
     
Restrictions on Individual & Student Members

Membership benefits:
      Networking
      Membership listings
     
Annual Conference
      ----------------------------
     
Use the ILDA Member logo
     
Enter the ILDA Awards
     
Receive inquiries
      ----------------------------
     
Member Discount Program
 
    Insurance
     -----------------------------
     
Help set standards
    
 Access to ILDA Standards
      -----------------------------
     
Work on committees
     
Ethics Committee
    
 Input to regulatory agencies
     
"Self-help"

Member Discount Program
----------------------------
Ethics and business:
      Code of Ethics
     
Code of Business Practice
     
Code of Bus. Pr. FAQ
      Ethics Complaint Form
       -----------------------------
     
Intellectual property tips

      2010 warning - OpenGL artware piracy

Accreditation & certification programs
      Overview
      Required elements
      "ILDA Professional" IAPLC program

Laser safety basics

 

 

 
   About ILDA

Contact us
Permission to reprint ILDA material
----------------------------
What we do:
     Our mission
     Protecting the industry
     What does it mean that a company is an ILDA Member?
     ILDA's power and limits

     -----------------------------
     Articles by and about ILDA


Board, Executive Director & committees:
     
Board and Executive Director
     
Board duties
      Running and voting for the Board
     
Committees
      Volunteer opportunities
      -----------------------------
      ILDA's power and limits

Our history:
     Founding meeting, 1986
     Founding Members, 1986
  
  ILDA timeline, 1986-present
     -----------------------------
    
List of past ILDA Award winners
    
List of past ILDA Conferences
    
List of past Board members
     -----------------------------
     Current "What's new" page (for this year)
     Past "What's new" pages:
            2010
     2009
            2008    
2007  
            2006

 
 

   The ILDA Conference

Future conferences

Previous conferences:
     -----------------------------
    
2011 Nov., Moscow
          Post-conference report
    
Pre-conference information:
          Overview, registration, attendees

     -----------------------------
     2010 Sept., cruise #2 from Miami
          Tim Walsh's diary
          Attendees
          Pre-conference information:
               Overview and registration
               Reservations and travel
     -----------------------------
      2009 June, Amsterdam
          Overview and photos
          Technology Workshop
           Pre-conference information:
               ILDA Member registration
               Non-member registration
     -----------------------------
    
 2008 Sept., cruise from Miami
            Post-conference report
            Tim Walsh's diary
            Attendees

            Pre-conference information:
                Overview
                Photo preview
                Reservations and getting there
     
          Conference registration
        
       Sponsorship opportunities
                Logo contest (deadline 6/30)
     -----------------------------
      2007 March, Heshan, China:
           About the 2007 Conference
           List of attendees
     
2006 March, Rimini, Italy
     
List of past conferences

About conferences:
      Conferences: A general overview
      Conference hosting guide
 
 

   The ILDA Awards

2011 Award winners

Previous ILDA Award winners

    
List of all artistic & tech winners
     List of all Career Achievement Award winners
     Winners by year:
                                                  2011

         
2010  2009  2008  2007  2006
         
2005  2004  2003  2002  2001
         
2000  1999  1998  1997  1996
         
1995  1994  1993  1992  1991
         
1990  1989  1988     

Awards overview
Judging guidelines

----------------------------
2012 entry forms
2011 entry forms
ILDA Award trophy photos (Members only)

 

   The Laserist magazine